Christmas-tree-shaped snack cakes on a plate next to an open tin of white paint

Hey {{first_name|there}}

If you've been on TikTok or Instagram this month, you've seen them. Christmas Tree Cakes. In lattes, in dips, toasted over a fire, eaten two boxes at a time.

And then this week a video took off saying the snow-white frosting is made white with a paint pigment.

Clip from our video: Christmas Tree Cakes made white with paint pigment

From our Christmas Tree Cakes video. Footage: USA TODAY, Pexels.

So I flipped the box over and checked. It's true. It's printed right there on the label.

But honestly, that's not the part that bothered me most. There's a second ingredient on the same label that matters more if you have a sensitive gut. Almost nobody is talking about it.

Let's get into it. ☕

QUICK POLL

No judgment. They're a once-a-year thing for a lot of us.

Be honest: is there a box of Christmas Tree Cakes (or any holiday snack cakes) in your house right now?

Login or Subscribe to participate

CURATED GOODIES

This week's reads worth your time 🔖

Reading glasses, coffee, a newspaper and a snack cake with its label facing up

01 — Titanium dioxide: E171 no longer considered safe when used as a food additive (EFSA, May 2021) Europe's food safety agency reviewed the white coloring and said a concern that it could damage DNA "could not be ruled out". Because of that, they couldn't set any safe daily amount. The EU then banned it from food in 2022.

→ Europe's own experts wouldn't call it safe. So Europe took it out of food.

02 — Consumer Reports: FDA policy change affects artificial colors in food (WMUR News 9, April 2026) "No artificial colors" on the front of a box used to mean no added colors at all. Now it only means no petroleum dyes like Red 40. Titanium dioxide doesn't count. As Consumer Reports' Paris Martineau put it: "Now you could have that in a product labeled 'no artificial colors.'"

→ The front of the box sells. The back of the box tells.

03 — Dietary emulsifiers impact the mouse gut microbiota promoting colitis and metabolic syndrome (Nature, 2015) The study behind the gut part of today's issue. Researchers gave mice two common food emulsifiers, including polysorbate 80, and watched what happened to their gut lining. More on that below.

→ It was in mice, not people. But it's why gut researchers started looking at emulsifiers at all.

MAIN FEATURE

I Flipped Over a Box of Christmas Tree Cakes. Here's What's on the Back.

1. The white frosting: titanium dioxide

Near the end of the label, in the "2% or less" part: titanium dioxide (color).

The ingredient label with titanium dioxide highlighted, then the EU flag

Titanium dioxide is the main white pigment in house paint. It's also in mineral sunscreen. In food it's used for one reason: to make things look whiter and brighter.

In Europe, it's been banned from food since 2022. In the US it's still allowed, up to 1% of the food's weight. The FDA is still reviewing a 2023 petition asking it to remove that permission.

Animation: titanium dioxide is banned in Europe since 2022 and still allowed in the USA

To be fair: the food-grade version isn't the same product as the paint in your garage. But it's the same pigment, and Europe decided it wasn't worth the risk for a color.

📺 In the news this year

In June, Consumer Reports published a test of 40 popular US foods, from chips and snack cakes to drink mixes and pudding. One in four had what it called "concerning amounts of additives". Titanium dioxide was one of the additives named, and some of the companies told Consumer Reports they're now working to remove it.

News clip: Consumer Reports found one quarter of tested products had concerning amounts of additives

Clip: Arizona's Family (KTVK) / Consumer Reports, June 2026

The catch, as their reporter pointed out on the news: companies don't have to tell you how much of an additive is in each serving. The label only tells you it's there.

2. The part nobody's talking about: polysorbate 80

Same ingredient list: polysorbate 80. It's an emulsifier. It keeps the frosting smooth and stops the fat and water from separating.

The ingredient label with polysorbate 80 highlighted

In the 2015 Nature study above, mice that got polysorbate 80 in their drinking water ended up with gut bacteria creeping closer to the gut wall, through the mucus layer that normally keeps them at a distance. The mice developed low-grade gut inflammation, and they gained weight.

Animation: in mice, polysorbate 80 thinned the gut's mucus layer and bacteria moved closer to the gut wall

Again, that was mice, and the doses aren't the same as one snack cake. But if your gut is already sensitive, it's worth knowing what's holding that frosting together.

And if you bloat easily, there's more on the label: wheat, milk ingredients and soy flour are all on the Monash University watch-list for gas and bloating.

3. What I'd actually do

I'm not going to tell you to never eat one. It's Christmas.

But there's a big difference between one at a party and a box a week from now until New Year's. If they've become a daily thing in your house, that's the one habit I'd change.

The swap: make the frosting yourself (recipe below). It won't be paint-white. It'll be a soft cream color. That's what real frosting looks like.

❝

If a food needs a paint pigment to look the way it does, that tells you something about the food.

HOW TO SPOT IT ON ANY LABEL

Animation: a box says no artificial colors, and the back still lists titanium dioxide
  1. Skip the front of the box. "No artificial colors" no longer rules out titanium dioxide.

  2. Go to the "2% or less" part of the ingredients. That's where it usually hides, written as "titanium dioxide (color)" or "color (titanium dioxide)".

  3. Check anything that's unusually white or bright. Frosting, icing, candy coatings and chewing gum are the usual places.

THE 5-MINUTE SNOW-WHITE(ISH) FROSTING

Homemade tree-shaped cakes with cream-colored frosting and red stripes

For homemade tree cakes, cupcakes or sugar cookies. No pigment needed.

  1. 4 oz cream cheese and 4 tbsp butter, both soft.

  2. Beat in 1 cup of powdered sugar, a little at a time. Most recipes say two cups. You won't miss it.

  3. Add 1 tsp vanilla and a pinch of salt. Beat for 2 minutes until fluffy.

  4. Pipe on a few red stripes with a drop of beet juice in a little of the frosting.

That's it. Kids love decorating these, and you know exactly what's in them.

SCAN YOUR HOLIDAY SNACKS

I checked this label with Unjunk AI, the label scanner we've been building for you. When you scan the barcode, it flags titanium dioxide as banned in EU food. If your gut type is "Bloating and gas", it also says "May trigger your symptoms" and shows you which ingredients are why.

Unjunk AI scan of Christmas Tree Cakes: banned in the EU and may trigger your symptoms

Do the same with whatever is in your cupboard this month: the cookies, the candy, the hot chocolate mix. It checks every ingredient against what Europe allows, and against your gut.

7 days free, then $9.69/month. Cancel anytime.

MICRO SOCIAL CONTENT

Shareable 1: "The white frosting on Christmas Tree Cakes gets its color from titanium dioxide, the same white pigment used in house paint. Europe banned it from food in 2022."

Shareable 2: "'No artificial colors' on the front of a box no longer rules out titanium dioxide. Read the back."

Shareable 3: "Same label, second ingredient to know: polysorbate 80. In mice, it let gut bacteria creep through the protective mucus and caused low-grade inflammation."

OUTRO

Hit reply and tell me which holiday treat you want me to flip over next, and I'll put it in next week's issue.

And if you know someone who buys these by the box, forward this to them. They'll want to read the back before the next one.

Talk soon,

Wilson From Nature The Cure 🌿

P.S. The white comes from a paint pigment. The smooth comes from an emulsifier. Flip the box. It's never just cake.

Keep Reading